Meta and encrypted messaging service Signal pushed back against Canada’s proposed data-access legislation during a Senate committee hearing on November 16, 2026. The companies warned that requirements for technical assistance and data retention could undermine the privacy and security of their services. The dispute concerns Bill C-22, known as the Lawful Access Act, 2026, which remains under parliamentary review.
Canada’s Senate national security committee examined the legislation with representatives from Meta, Signal and other technology companies, according to the official committee meeting notice. The witnesses included Meta’s Rachel Curran and Robyn Greene, Signal’s Udbhav Tiwari and representatives from Tailscale. Their concerns focused on how the proposed law could affect encrypted communications and the information companies must retain about users.
Bill C-22 is designed to give Canadian police and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) more effective ways to obtain digital information during authorized investigations. The proposed legislation would require certain electronic service providers to develop or maintain capabilities that help investigators access information through existing legal powers. However, the bill does not mean police would automatically gain unrestricted access to private conversations.
One disputed provision would allow regulations requiring certain service providers to retain specified categories of metadata for periods of up to six months. Metadata can include details about communications, such as when they occurred, rather than the messages themselves. The amended text of Bill C-22 prevents these retention regulations from requiring companies to store message content, personal web-browsing history or social media activities.
The legislation would also introduce a judicial production order for subscriber information, including certain account or identifying details. Under the proposed rules, a judge or justice could authorize such an order based on reasonable grounds to suspect that an offence has been or will be committed and that the information would help the investigation. Privacy advocates have questioned whether this standard provides sufficient protection for sensitive personal information.
Meta argues that parts of the legislation could still pressure companies to weaken encryption or install government or third-party surveillance tools. In its earlier public statement on Bill C-22, the company supported lawful access to evidence but requested stronger encryption safeguards and clearer procedures for challenging technical orders. During the November 16 hearing, Greene said the amendments had not resolved Meta’s concerns, according to reporting by The Canadian Press.
Signal has gone further in explaining how it might respond if compliance requires compromising its security model. The company’s vice-president of strategy and global affairs, Udbhav Tiwari, previously said Signal would rather withdraw from Canada than weaken the protections promised to its users, according to Global News reporting. That warning is conditional. Signal has not announced that its messaging service is shutting down in Canada.
The Canadian government disputes the suggestion that Bill C-22 requires companies to create encryption backdoors. Its official explanation of the legislation says the amended bill includes safeguards against systemic security vulnerabilities. It also says companies cannot be compelled to decrypt information unless they supplied the encryption and possess the information needed to decrypt it. The government maintains that investigators would still need proper legal authorization to obtain personal information.
Concerns extend beyond the technology industry. In a November 2 statement to the Senate committee, Canada’s Privacy Commissioner welcomed improvements to the bill but recommended further safeguards. These included narrower rules for subscriber information, stronger requirements for necessity and proportionality, and independent assessment of technical obligations that could create security vulnerabilities.
For people using WhatsApp, Signal and other privacy-focused services, the main concern is how future technical requirements might affect the security of their communications. End-to-end encryption protects message contents so that providers ordinarily cannot read them, while metadata can reveal information about communication patterns. The proposed law raises questions about both protections, although it does not establish that existing encrypted conversations have been compromised.
No immediate change to messaging services is required from Canadian users because of the Senate debate. Bill C-22 has not become law, and the final wording and practical effects of any requirements remain uncertain. The next important development will be whether senators recommend further amendments to address the concerns raised by technology companies, privacy advocates and government officials.
Tech Bonafide is the editorial identity of TechBonafide, an independent technology publication covering AI, software, cybersecurity, gadgets, and emerging technology.